Hospital Negligence in New York: A Floor-by-Floor Look at Where Things Go Wrong

When most people hear "malpractice" they picture one careless doctor, and sure, sometimes that's what it is. With hospitals, though, what we usually find when we get the records is more of a pile-up, where the ER was two nurses short that night, a lab result came back and nobody picked up the phone, the pharmacy let through a dose that was ten times what it should've been, and then the patient got discharged early because somebody upstairs needed the bed. Any one of those, on its own, might not have hurt anyone. Stack them up, though, and you end up with a brain injury, or an amputation, or a family planning a funeral.

So rather than bore you with legal definitions, we figured it'd be more useful to walk through a hospital the way you actually experience one, from the moment you come through the ER doors until the day they send you home, and point out where hospital negligence tends to creep in. Along the way we'll answer the question we get asked more than any other: can you sue a hospital for negligence in New York, or only the doctor?

(Short answer to that one: yes, you often can sue the hospital itself, and a good hospital malpractice lawyer will usually name it. The longer answer is below. And look, if you've been up at 1 a.m. typing "hospital negligence NYC" or "sue hospital for malpractice" into Google, we get it, that's honestly who we wrote this for.)

Stop 1: The emergency room

A huge share of the hospital malpractice cases we see start in the ER, which isn't shocking when you think about how an emergency department works on a busy night in Brooklyn: the doctor has never laid eyes on you, has no history in front of them, and has three ambulances pulling in while they're trying to figure you out. That pressure is real, and it's exactly the reason there are strict rules about triage, testing and follow-up in the first place.

Most of the emergency room negligence we run into falls into one of three buckets.

• Triage that underestimates the patient. A 35-year-old with chest pain gets told it's probably stress, or somebody with bad belly pain sits in the waiting room for four hours because they didn't look that sick, and it's their appendix bursting.
• Emergency room failure to diagnose. The usual suspects here are heart attacks, strokes, blood clots, sepsis, meningitis and internal bleeding, where either the test that would've caught it never got ordered, or it got ordered and the result was just sitting there when the patient walked out.
• Sending people home too fast. You get sent out the door with a diagnosis that doesn't really match what's going on with you, and nobody tells you clearly what should make you come right back.

If something like this happened to you, an ER malpractice lawyer is going to want the triage notes, the timestamps on every order, and the discharge paperwork, because emergency room medical malpractice cases are almost always about timing.

Stop 2: Surgery and the operating room

Operating on the wrong knee, leaving a sponge inside somebody, nicking the bowel and not catching it, messing up the anesthesia. Some of these mistakes are so basic that hospitals themselves call them "never events," because, well, they're never supposed to happen. Hospitals are responsible for the systems that are supposed to prevent them, like time-outs before the first cut and counting sponges and instruments at the end. When those systems get skipped, the hospital shares the blame with the surgeon. Our surgical error lawyer page goes into operating-room cases in more detail.

Stop 3: The hospital floor

Once you're admitted, the risks get quieter but they don't go away.

Meds are a big source of trouble. We see a hospital medication error in all kinds of forms, from the wrong drug or a dose with an extra zero on it to a patient getting their roommate's pills, or a penicillin allergy you told three different people about somehow never landing in the chart. Doctors, nurses and pharmacists all touch this process, and the hospital is supposed to have checks in place so one person's slip gets caught by the next. (If it was a retail pharmacy that messed up and not the hospital, our page on pharmacy malpractice may be more useful.)

Then there's monitoring. Bedsores that get so deep you can see bone, an elderly patient climbing out of a bed that had no alarm and breaking a hip, somebody fresh out of surgery whose oxygen sinks overnight while nobody comes in to check. A lot of that traces back to not having enough staff on the floor, and how many nurses to schedule is a choice the hospital makes.

Infections are a harder call, to be honest. People do pick up infections in hospitals even when the staff did everything by the book, so an infection alone doesn't prove much. What hospital acquired infection malpractice cases tend to turn on is whether basic infection control was followed (hand hygiene, sterile technique with central lines and catheters, isolating contagious patients) and whether the infection was caught and treated quickly once it showed up.

Stop 4: Labor and delivery

Childbirth is one of the most common reasons people end up in a New York hospital, and when something goes wrong it can affect two lives. Missed signs of fetal distress on the monitor, a C-section done too late, a maternal hemorrhage that isn't controlled. These cases overlap heavily with what our birth injury attorneys handle.

Stop 5: Discharge

This one surprises people. Getting sent home is supposed to be good news, but a hospital unsafe discharge is a real and fairly common problem. Patients get released while still unstable, without the follow-up appointments they need, without anyone confirming they can actually manage at home, or before test results that are still pending come back. We've seen elderly patients discharged to an empty apartment the same day they could barely stand. When the predictable thing then happens, the hospital's decision to discharge is part of the case.

So who can you actually sue?

This is where hospital cases get legally interesting, and it's the reason it's worth talking to a hospital malpractice attorney or hospital negligence attorney instead of guessing. Medical malpractice hospital cases almost never have just one name on them.

Who made the mistake	Is the hospital usually responsible?	Why
Nurse, resident, technician, pharmacist employed by the hospital	Yes, typically	A hospital answers for its own employees' negligence on the job
ER doctor who is an independent contractor	Often, yes	If the patient came to the ER and reasonably believed the doctor worked for the hospital, New York courts have held the hospital can be responsible
Private attending physician you chose	Not automatically	The doctor is usually liable personally; the hospital may be liable if its own staff should have stepped in
A doctor who never should have had privileges	Possibly	Hospital negligent credentialing: New York law (Public Health Law § 2805-k) requires hospitals to check a doctor's background before granting privileges
The hospital's own policies, staffing, equipment	Yes	Understaffing, broken monitors and missing protocols are the hospital's own negligence

In practice, most hospital negligence lawsuits name several defendants at once: the hospital, one or more doctors, sometimes a physician group. Figuring out exactly who employed whom takes digging, and it's one of the first things we do in any hospital negligence claim.

Public hospitals: the 90-day trap

Hospital negligence in New York has one rule that catches more families off guard than any other, and it depends on who owns the building.

If the care happened at a public hospital, such as one of the NYC Health + Hospitals facilities (Kings County, Coney Island, Elmhurst, Bellevue and others), the rules change in a big way. You generally have to file a notice of claim within 90 days, and the lawsuit itself usually has to start within one year and 90 days. Miss the notice and the case can be over before it starts.

For private hospitals, the general medical malpractice deadline is 2 years and 6 months, with some exceptions. Our article on the New York medical malpractice statute of limitations explains those.

What a hospital malpractice claim can recover

Hospital negligence compensation (and this goes for hospital malpractice New York cases anywhere in the state, not just the city) can include medical bills (past and future), lost income, the cost of care at home or in a facility, and pain and suffering. New York doesn't cap damages in malpractice cases. If a patient died because of hospital negligence, the family may bring a wrongful death claim.

We won't throw out an "average" number, because there isn't a meaningful one. A hospital malpractice lawsuit over a missed fracture and one over a brain injury from a medication overdose aren't comparable.

Before you call anyone, do these three things

1. Write it down. Dates, names of staff if you know them, what you were told and when. Hospital stays blur together fast.
2. Ask for the full record. Not just the discharge summary. Nursing notes, medication administration records, lab results and imaging. You're entitled to them.
3. Don't sign a release or talk to the hospital's risk management office about what happened until you've gotten advice. They're not calling to help you build a case.

Talk to a hospital negligence lawyer in New York

The Rybak Firm, PLLC is based in Brooklyn and handles hospital malpractice NYC cases in all five boroughs, against private hospitals and public ones. Hospital negligence New York claims are a big part of what our malpractice team does, from Brooklyn and Staten Island hospitals to the large Manhattan medical centers. If you think you or a family member were hurt by hospital negligence in New York, talk to a hospital medical malpractice lawyer on our team. We'll dig through the records with you and give you a straight answer on whether it's worth pursuing, and if it isn't, we'll tell you that too. You can request a free case review online, or just call us at (718) 307-5554.

Attorney Advertising. This article is general information, not legal advice. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

FAQ